Sarasota, Florida -- Sarasota Sheriff's deputies arrested the woman they say shot and killed her boyfriend in their Ranchero Drive home in Sarasota on Aug. 4.
Detectives say Karli Wilbanks, 25, called 911 just before 1:00 p.m. that day claiming that someone was trying to kill her. When deputies responded, they found 41-year-old Michael Goodman dead from multiple gunshot wounds.
Wilbanks was taken to Sarasota Memorial Hospital for heart issues and spoke with detectives that night before being released while the investigation continued.
Wilbanks told detectives that Goodman said he was going to kill her and quickly moved toward her. She said she fired warning shots and then shot him. During the investigation, interviews and forensic evidence raised questions that Wilbanks could not explain.
Detectives spoke with friends and neighbors who said while Wilbanks told them about physical abuse, they never saw any marks on her and never saw Goodman get angry with her. Most friends said that Goodman wanted to take care of Wilbanks and could not fathom him hurting her. In addition, acquaintances who attended a party at the Ranchero Drive home in May reported that Wilbanks was jealous about a girl at the party and said she would kill Goodman.
Karli Wilbanks has been charged with second degree murder. She is currently being held without bond.