Breaking News
More () »

Church transformed into luxury home in St. Petersburg sells for $1.4 million

Developers turned the 1928 Grace Lutheran Church into a luxury home after a neighborhood association fought to save the historic building.

SAINT PETERSBURG, Fla. — In the middle of St. Pete’s Crescent Heights neighborhood, a unique house that was only on the market for a few weeks sold for more than its asking price. 

Originally built as Grace Lutheran Church back in 1928, it was once a gathering place for worship, voting and special events.

So when a developer bought the property with plans to tear the church down, the neighborhood association fought to keep the sanctuary standing.

“They decided that they wanted to have the church declared historical,” said home developer Scott Herald, who invested in the project.

Herald worked with builder Jason Sanchez and the city of St. Petersburg to come up with an alternate plan which included saving the original church sanctuary and transforming it into a home while leaving the outside unchanged.

An architect designed the interior, transforming this near 100-year-old house of God into a house for the living.

RELATED: Church transformed into luxury home up for sale in St. Petersburg

Credit: Bryan Belcher
A look at the inside of what was originally the Grace Lutheran Church. Developers transformed the building into a luxury home.

“It’s a well balance between old and new and that is what we were looking for,” said Herald of the finished project.

Inside you can pull up a pew at the dinner table or head upstairs for a good night’s sleep.

"The master bedroom is the choir loft,” Sanchez said. There’s even a swimming pool out back.

The home went on the market just a few weeks back and did not stay there long. 

"I had an offer in hand the first hour of it hitting the market,” said realtor Bryan Belcher, who confirms even the neighborhood association is pleased with how the project turned out.

“I was scheduled to have what I thought was about 10 people the walk-through on Wednesday night. I ended up having over 200 people walk through the property.  Some of them went to church there as children and haven’t been there in the church since they were 6, 7, 8 years old,” Belcher said.

There’s no doubt it was a challenging project filled with frustration, but the developers say the hard work is now all paying off. 

The home was expected to go above the asking price, which is around $1.3 million. And it did, it closed at $1.4 million. 

“It’s truly been a rewarding and learning experience,” Herald said. “We’re just thrilled that we’re at the point they we are at.”

You can read more about the original church's history here.

RELATED: 'Construction time is slowing down and time is money': Cost of building new homes skyrockets

What other people are reading right now:

►Breaking news and weather alerts: Get the free 10 Tampa Bay app

Stay In the Know! Sign up now for the Brightside Blend Newsletter